A recent Australian report has cast a spotlight on the Chinese regime’s intention to rival other major powers including the United States, Australia, and Japan in the Indo-Pacific region.
The report, titled “Ocean horizons: Strengthening maritime security in Indo-Pacific island states,” was published by Canberra-based think tank Australian Strategic Policy Institute on Dec. 5.
Chinese influence and investment in the region, some of which is carried out through its foreign policy initiative known was “One Belt One Road” (OBOR, also known as “Belt and Road,” BRI), can have “financial, strategic, and sovereignty implications” since countries could take on unsustainable Chinese debts, the report said.
China rolled out OBOR in 2013 to build up Beijing-centered land and maritime trade networks by financing infrastructure projects throughout Southeast Asia, Africa, and Europe.
In 2017, Sri Lanka handed over control of its key port of Hambantota to Beijing in a 99-year lease, to pay off over $1 billion in debt for the port project. The incident has been seen as a case-study in the regime’s “debt-trap diplomacy,” the report noted.
It said that the Pacific Island states of Tonga, Samoa, and Vanuatu, “appear to be among those most heavily indebted to China anywhere in the world.”
The regime also intends to exert some military influence through OBOR. According to the report, China’s Defense Minister Wei Fenge in 2019 told a gathering of military leaders from the South Pacific and the Caribbean in Beijing, how OBOR would provide a “framework” for military cooperation.
In 2018, both the United States and Australia were alarmed when Vanuatu signed a $100 million port project with China with possible military applications, though both countries denied the agreement involved building up a Chinese military base, the report said.
“China also has growing economic and demographic interests in each region [Pacific and Indian Oceans] that could drive future military responses. Growing investments, including as part of the BRI, create new interests to be protected,” it said.
Pacific Island Countries
Beijing has a clear diplomatic and strategic agenda in South Asia, including interest in the region’s fish stocks and minerals, much at the expense of U.S. allies Australia and Taiwan, the report noted.
Additionally, for Australia, any Chinese military facility would be a “significant threat,” particularly to the key sea lanes linking the country to the United States.
In a February 2018 article, ASPI pointed out that Australia was dependent on trade routes in Southeast Asia, including important choke points such as the Strait of Malacca, Sunda and Lombok Straits. If these routes and those in East and South China Seas became contested waters, the country would need to secure alternative routes through the Banda Sea and the east of Papua New Guinea—both of which are located to the north of Australia.
“The recent switching of diplomatic allegiance from Taiwan to China by Solomon Islands and Kiribati underscores the difficulties of the China challenge when Beijing is willing to offer large sums of money to small states,” the report stated.
Beijing considers Taiwan a renegade province that should be united with the mainland, with military force if necessary, despite the fact that the island is a de-facto independent polity with its own military and democratically-elected officials.
The Chinese regime has thus taken different tactics to diminish Taiwan’s legitimacy as a state. In recent years, it has lured away Taiwan’s diplomatic allies with Chinese investment and loans—in what critics call “dollar diplomacy.”
Taiwan has lost seven allies since 2016: El Salvador, Burkina Faso, the Dominican Republic, Panama, São Tomé and Príncipe, the Solomon Islands, and Kiribati.
Taiwan’s government-run media outlet Central News Agency reported that Beijing promised the Solomon Islands $500 million in aid for the diplomatic switch.
Chinese criminals have also set up operations in Pacific Islands countries. According to the report, Chinese human traffickers have used Palau and Fiji as transit points for other destinations within the region.
Indian Ocean Island States
The Chinese regime now has control of several ports in the India Ocean, including Pakistan’s Gwadar port, Maldives’ Feydhoo Finolhu Port, and Sri Lanka’s Hambantota Port—as well as a military base in the small African country of Djibouti.
“We should expect the opening of other bases (or at least logistical support facilities) in the future in the western, central and eastern Indian Ocean,” the report predicted, given the regime’s dependence on trade routes in the region, particularly through the Strait of Malacca, to ship its energy imports.
Similar to the South Pacific, the Indian Ocean’s rich fish stocks were also of interest to China.
“Madagascar, with weak governance institutions and significant natural resources, also has the potential to become the target of predatory initiatives from China,” the report stated.
It explained that there had been “non-transparent attempts” by Chinese companies to obtain fishing rights in the East African country’s exclusive economic zones.
All of the small nations in both Indian and the Pacific Oceans were vulnerable when dealing with bigger countries, the report warned.
“Their size and institutional weaknesses also place island states at a big disadvantage in dealing with large countries that may seek to gain undue economic or political influence,” it said.
The report offered several suggestions for these nations.
“The Indo-Pacific island states should work together to strengthen regional norms that will help them resist economic coercion and enhance transparency in decision-making,” it said.
The report also called on Australia, Japan, India, and the United States to coordinate their coast guard agencies to provide assistance to release nations.